• Foodbuzz

Henri’s French Onion Soup

  • Archives:
  • Entrees, Soups

    I don’t know who Henri is, but I would like to kiss this man.  Since going vegetarian (ahem, pescetarian), I realized that enjoying the things that I used to like, i.e. French onion soup, usually contains things like beef or chicken stock.  I was totally disappointed and was hoping to find another substitute for a soup base.  I thought about experimenting with vegetable stock, but, to be honest, the dark, rustic taste of French onion would  (I thought) be severely compromised by the addition of a vegetable base.

    And, then, I found Henri.  Oh, Henri.  You have changed my world.  Just kidding.  I was just super excited to get the same great taste in a soup WITHOUT having to use a meat stock.  And, even though the prep/cook time (at least 1 1/2 hours) was a little long, it was a rainy Saturday, and I had nothing else to do.  The kitchen smelled amazing, I drank a (few) glass(es) of the dry white wine, and the end product was nothing short of one of the best crocks of French onion soup I have ever had.  Here’s to rainy days in the summer……and to Henri.

    Henri’s French Onion Soup

    Serves 6.

    INGREDIENTS

    3 pounds yellow onions, cut into 1/8-inch pieces
    3 tablespoons unsalted butter
    1/2 teaspoon table salt, plus more as needed
    1 pinch sugar
    8 cups water , plus more as needed
    1 tablespoon all-purpose flour
    1 sprig fresh thyme
    1/4 cup dry white wine
    1 baguette , crusty
    8 ounces Gruyère cheese-I sliced it thick and placed it over the top of the crock…..the cheese melted mostly into the soup and a little off to the sides, but it created a thick, even layer this way.

    INSTRUCTIONS

    1. Melt butter in a large Dutch oven or soup pot over medium heat.
    2. Add the onions, 1/2 teaspoon salt, and sugar. Toss to evenly coat.
    3. Cover and cook for 10 minutes.
    4. Take the cover off, and cook, stirring frequently, until the onions are lightly browned.  I cooked mine for a little less than 90 minutes.
    5. At this point, stir every 5 minutes and add water (a tablespoon at a time to loosen up the dark brown stuff that forms on the bottom of the pan).
    6. Continue to cook until the onions are an even dark brown color, an additional 30 minutes longer or so.
    7. Add the flour and stir for two minutes.
    8. Add 8 cups water and thyme to the onions and bring to a boil.
    9. Lower heat  and simmer for 20 minutes.
    10. Add white wine and simmer 10 minutes longer.
    11. Add salt to taste.
    12. Meanwhile, heat the oven to 325 degrees and adjust a rack to the upper middle position.
    13. Cut the baguette into 3/4 inch slices and arrange on a single layer on a cookie sheet.
    14. Bake until the bread is dry, about 10 minutes. Remove bread slices and set aside.
    15. Heat broiler and place 6 heatproof bowls in a baking sheet. Fill each bowl with about 2 cups soup. Top each with two baguette slices and evenly distribute cheese slices over the bread. Broil until well browned and bubbly, about ten minutes. Cool for five minutes before serving.                                                                                                                                                                                                       Barely adapted from Cook’s Illustrated. (I’m on a roll…….)

    Related posts:

    61 Comments

    44 Comments

    1. jacobskitchen  •  Aug 7, 2010 @8:03 pm

      Wow! That looks so amazing! I love me some French onion soup. =)

    2. Simran Stacie  •  Aug 7, 2010 @9:55 pm

      This looks like a good one. We are trying to eat more vegetarian stuff – and this looks like a good recipe!

    3. Carla  •  Aug 8, 2010 @1:48 pm

      That is the best dang French onion soup I have ever seen in my life. Holy mangoes, Batman!

    4. Adrien  •  Aug 11, 2010 @4:21 pm

      I’m French, I love oignon soup, I tried the recipe tonight, and i can tell you : it was great!

    5. Kathryn  •  Aug 13, 2010 @11:56 am

      That looks delish! You should try my favorite split pea soup with kielbasa- it amazing!

    6. srlacy  •  Aug 13, 2010 @12:23 pm

      Thanks Kathryn!

      I love split pea soup and will be on the look-out for a vegetarian friendly one! Thanks for sharing!

      Shanon

    7. Vegolicious  •  Oct 23, 2010 @7:07 am

      Wow, this looks amazing!!

      I’d love for you to submit one of your beautiful photos, and a link to your post, to my new vegetarian food photo gallery showcasing beautiful and flavorful vegetarian food.

    8. Alejandrina Barnaba  •  Nov 22, 2010 @7:06 am

      Thanks, and for anyone that is having trouble chopping onions without the crying, here’s an incredibly easy tip – put them in the fridge for a few hours, then chop them straight away after taking them out! No more tears! I found some more onion soup recipes here if anyone wants to try some more recipes.

    9. Katie  •  Feb 8, 2011 @3:44 pm

      I made this today and it was SO delicious. My boufriend couldn’t even tell it was vegetarian. Thanks for posting!

    10. Ashley  •  Feb 26, 2011 @10:33 pm

      Wowza! I’m eating this right now and I think I love Henri too! Thank you so much for the amazing recipe! I would love to share this on my blog (with your permission of course)! What a gem of a recipe! Thank you thank you and happy cooking =)))

    11. srlacy  •  Feb 27, 2011 @8:39 am

      Ashley-thanks!! By all means, feel free to share. Just be sure to include the original source as well :) .
      I’m so glad you liked it!
      Shanon

    12. Susan  •  Jul 26, 2011 @12:20 pm

      WOW!! amazing photo…I am going to try your recipe, thanks for such a great recipe

    13. Laura  •  Sep 1, 2011 @11:09 pm

      I have always made onion soup with a veggie broth base(no mushrooms).. and without the cheese or wine. Having to also keep it gluten free I use a flax or rice round instead of the wheat bread; the soy- dairy free “faux” cheese product adds the melted look if first drizzled with a bit of “EVOO”. I use rice flour for the rue; and a variety of diced onions: sweet, yellow, white, purple and a few green onions!

    14. Tara Martinez  •  Sep 21, 2011 @10:18 am

      French onion soup has never appealed to me, until I saw this picture!! It looks delish!!

    15. Elle  •  Oct 3, 2011 @10:36 am

      How do the 8 cups of water not completely water down this soup?

    16. srlacy  •  Oct 3, 2011 @12:49 pm

      Hi Elle-

      They don’t. Initially I thought that as well, and I was definitely surprised by the fantastic flavor that remained after adding all that water. This recipe is a keeper!

    17. Carrie  •  Oct 19, 2011 @12:27 pm

      is everyone using the cheese in the recipe? I thought it was swiss?!?!

    18. courtney  •  Nov 9, 2011 @1:05 pm

      Do you really mean to cook onions for 90 minutes? Or 9?

    19. srlacy  •  Nov 9, 2011 @8:08 pm

      Hi Courtney-

      Yep. It’s really 90 minutes. It’s a long time to cook onions, but it’s really really worth it, I promise.

    20. Susan McNamara  •  Nov 12, 2011 @9:00 pm

      I couldn’t find a vegetarian gruyère anywhere! I tried whole foods even but nothin:( I’m still making this though:)

    21. Jen  •  Jan 10, 2012 @12:57 am

      this is pretty much the exact recipe that my french maman taught me. delish!

    22. Anna @BeanBugCrafts  •  Jan 12, 2012 @6:19 pm

      Your soup recipe looks so yummy! I have featured it here:http://beanbugcrafts.blogspot.com/2012/01/warming-up-with-some-soup.html

      Thanks for sharing!

    23. Sue Hall  •  Feb 1, 2012 @8:32 pm

      My cheese fell into the soup and did not get all brown and crusty. It was still good but what can I do differently?

    24. srlacy  •  Feb 1, 2012 @8:49 pm

      Hi Sue-

      Try using a wide, thin-slice cheese that you can drape over the edges.

    25. Deb Lefebvre  •  Feb 5, 2012 @3:16 am

      Why the flour? Otherwise this would be Gluten Free. So again, why the flour?

    26. srlacy  •  Feb 5, 2012 @10:24 am

      The flour helps with the binding. If you want to keep it gluten free, try rice flour or another appropriate alternative.

    27. rachel  •  Feb 16, 2012 @1:25 am

      Is there any way to make this without using individual bowls in the oven? Or will that not bake the cheese as well?

    28. srlacy  •  Feb 16, 2012 @9:22 am

      Hi Rachel-

      You don’t necessarily need the bowls, but that’s probably the best way to get the cheese browned and slightly crispy on the top. If you just want melted cheese, you could use a normal (non-oven safe) bowl and microwave the soup to get the cheese melted on top.

    29. sarah  •  Feb 28, 2012 @8:56 pm

      What kind of wine did you use? I have seen a lot of recipes and they always say something like dry white, but i am relatively new to drinking and cooking with wine so what type should i look for?

    30. srlacy  •  Feb 28, 2012 @9:09 pm

      Hi Sarah-

      I can’t remember exactly what I used, but most likely it was either a Sauvignon Blanc or Pinot Grigio. You can use either one.

    31. Bobbi  •  Mar 5, 2012 @11:24 pm

      May I use your picture on Pinterest?
      Thank you!

    32. srlacy  •  Mar 6, 2012 @8:57 am

      Hi Bobbi-

      Sure, as long as there is a proper link back to the website. That way people can find the recipe! :)

    33. Marie  •  Mar 17, 2012 @9:02 pm

      Thank you for this recipe. Just made it tonight, improvised with croutons since I did not have crusty bread and provolone cheese. It was still incredible. Thank you!

    34. Brittney  •  Mar 23, 2012 @4:34 pm

      Can you freeze this soup?

    35. srlacy  •  Mar 23, 2012 @4:35 pm

      I’m sure you can, although I have not tried it.

    36. Stacy  •  Mar 28, 2012 @11:57 am

      This looks wonderful! I’m actually making it for dinner tonight but only have a block of sharp cheddar and a block of parmesan on hand. Would either of these work or should I run to the store to get the gruyere? I don’t want to spend all that time caramelizing the onions and then ruin it with the cheese! Thanks for your help!

    37. srlacy  •  Mar 28, 2012 @12:55 pm

      Hi Stacy-

      Sounds great, but I don’t want to steer you wrong with the cheese. This recipe IS a lot of work, so running for either Swiss or Gruyere would be worth it. I don’t think the Parmesan would broil properly for you. :)

    38. Ariel  •  Apr 2, 2012 @8:04 pm

      Looks and sounds delicious!! I am vegetarian and recently learned of different rennets (binding agent in chesses). Gruyere is almost always made with animal rennet, which is a complex of enzymes collected from the lining of the stomach of veal (baby cow). I cut certain cheese out of my diet because of this, and always check the labels on cheese. Just a note: Microbial and vegetable rennets are vegetarian approved! :) Thanks for sharing this delicious recipe. Can’t wait to try it!

    39. Leah  •  Apr 16, 2012 @2:53 pm

      what do you mean when you say cut onion into 1/8 inch pieces? Like a rough chop or keep the onion whole sliced into slices that are 1/8 inch thick?

    40. srlacy  •  Apr 16, 2012 @3:01 pm

      Hi Leah-

      Nice to meet you. You can do it either way, but the instructions mean to slice them into 1/8-inch thick slices.

    41. Leah  •  Apr 16, 2012 @3:11 pm

      Nice to meet you too! I am in the process of chopping/slicing so thanks for the quick reply! I chopped the first pound and sliced the last two. :) This looks awesome and thanks for sharing!

    42. Alyze  •  Apr 23, 2012 @11:06 am

      Finally made this last night after months of having it bookmarked and it was delicious!!!! You are so right, this recipe is a keeper! I am a vegetarian but my husband is not. French onion soup is one of his favorites and he was so skeptical a vegetarian version would have the right flavor, but he loved it so much he said after eating it he one with beef broth would just seem way too salty in comparison. Thanks for sharing!!

    43. Penelope Baker  •  May 9, 2012 @6:27 pm

      I haven’t made onion soup in ages but your recipe looks so wonderful I plan to serve it at a dinner party next week. I think I’ll follow it with my easy chicken rustica and a simple desert. That should knock ‘em dead!

      So thanks for sharing this. And pls take a peek at my site. I like to share too. :)

    44. Jewel  •  May 12, 2012 @2:07 am

      Looks beautiful. I do sometimes make French onion soup, and this recipe is similar to what I would normally use, so I’ll try it this way next time.

    17 Trackbacks

    Leave a Reply

    Allowed tags: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>



    Share |
    Creative Commons License
    The Curvy Carrot by Shanon Lacy is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 3.0 Unported License.
    Based on a work at www.thecurvycarrot.com.